16 Jan Hutton v. Breitkreutz

             THE COURT:  This case arises out of a motor vehicle accident that occurred on December 27, 2008. The basic facts of the accident are not in dispute, although liability is....

Read More

10 Dec Miller v. Marsden

             This case arises out of a motor vehicle accident that occurred nine years ago when the plaintiff Matthew Miller was 16 years old. The defendants Kathryn Marsden and Frederick Marsden admit liability for the accident but dispute the severity and impact of Mr. Miller’s injuries.II.               THE ACCIDENT...

Read More

26 Sep Hawkins v. Espiloy

             The plaintiff was injured in a rear-end collision while completing her nursing degree. Liability for the accident is admitted. The defendant disputes the extent of the plaintiff’s injuries and the need for the plaintiff to work part-time.BACKGROUND...

Read More

24 Jul Litt v. Guo

             THE COURT:  The defendants apply for a second medical examination of the plaintiff. The claims underlying the action are for personal injury, physical and psychological, arising out of two motor vehicle accidents that occurred in November 2003 and August 2010....

Read More

09 Jan Kumar v. Taba

             THE COURT:  On July 27, 2011, Naresh Kumar was driving his taxi southbound on Capilano Road towards the intersection with the Highway 1 west on-ramp. At the same time, Isabella Taba was driving her car northbound on Capilano Road. Just as she moved through the intersection, Mr. Kumar made a left turn and the two vehicles collided....

Read More

27 Nov Jang v. Ritchie

             THE COURT:  The plaintiff, Myong Su Jang, also known as John Jang, sues the defendant, Claude Ritchie, for damages. The defendant did not appear at trial. Mr. Ritchie had counsel for much of these proceedings. Counsel lost contact with his client and withdrew before trial. It appears Mr. Ritchie has chosen to avoid this litigation. He did not attend examination for discovery and, as noted, did not attend this trial to contest either liability or the amount of damages.THE ACCIDENT...

Read More

23 Aug Paller v. Regan

             THE COURT:  The plaintiff sues for compensation for injuries sustained in a car accident. Liability for the accident is admitted, but the defendants take the position that the mechanism of the accident could not have caused the injuries claimed by the plaintiff. Causation is thus in issue, as is the amount of damages.BACKGROUND...

Read More

11 Jun Woods v. Woods Estate

             The plaintiffs seek to set aside a testamentary gift made by their mother, Ola May Woods, to her granddaughter, the defendant Carmen Naomi Woods. The plaintiffs argue that the will was made in suspicious circumstances and that the gift was the result of undue influence or duress.BACKGROUND...

Read More

18 Apr Nelson v. Coyle

             THE COURT:  The plaintiff, Chastity Nelson, seeks damages for injuries sustained in three car accidents. The defendants, Messrs. Erwin, Coyle, and Chapman, admit liability for the accidents. In issue are, first, the effect of the injuries caused by the defendants' negligence and, second, the quantum of damages.BACKGROUND...

Read More

05 Mar Streeper Contracting Ltd. v. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia

             The plaintiff, Streeper Contracting Ltd., hauls oil rig equipment between lease sites in the oil and gas fields of northeastern British Columbia.  One of its heavy commercial trucks, Unit 50, collided head-on with another vehicle in December 2005.  The accident caused serious injury to the driver of Unit 50, the death of the third party driver, and the loss of both commercial vehicles.  The defendant, ICBC, denies coverage on the basis that Unit 50 was operating outside of its insurance coverage, and on the basis of a misstatement made to ICBC by Streeper Contracting’s president....

Read More